The Legend of the Mole People of NYC
The Origin of the Legend
The myth began to surface in the 1980s and early 1990s, when New York’s abandoned subway tunnels, old sewer systems, and forgotten Prohibition-era passageways became a subject of urban exploration. Journalists, documentarians, and thrill-seekers started sharing stories of encounters with people living in these dark, labyrinthine spaces.
The idea of “Mole People” grew out of a mix of truth and sensationalism.
The Real Basis: Tunnel Dwellers
The term “Mole People” was popularized by journalist Jennifer Toth in her 1993 book The Mole People: Life in the Tunnels Beneath New York City. She interviewed homeless individuals who had made homes in underground areas — building shacks, running generators, even creating social hierarchies and codes of conduct.
But critics later questioned the book's accuracy, saying some of the stories sounded too fantastical — secret societies with kings and rituals, or people who hadn't seen the sun in decades. That’s where the myth began to take on a life of its own.
The Creepy Evolution
In the darker versions of the legend, the Mole People aren’t just outcasts — they’ve mutated. Years away from the sunlight have turned them pale or even blind. They navigate using echolocation, or strange tunnel instincts. They’re said to be fiercely territorial — and dangerous to surface-dwellers who stray too deep into their domain.
Some tales say they speak a forgotten language or that they guard ancient relics buried under Manhattan. Others claim they were once victims of experiments — military or corporate — and were abandoned underground.
Secret Cities Beneath the Streets
The urban legend ties in with the truth that New York has multiple layers beneath it:
- Disused subway stations
- Prohibition-era smuggler’s tunnels
- 1800s sewer systems
- Old coal tunnels and utility lines
There are entire areas that city workers and even police rarely enter. Some explorers have claimed to find strange graffiti, makeshift furniture, or even shrines to unknown figures in the deepest tunnels.
In Pop Culture
The Mole People legend has inspired movies, books, and even comic books:
-
“C.H.U.D.” (1984) – A horror cult film about Cannibalistic Humanoid Underground Dwellers. Inspired by the Mole People myth.
-
“Us” (2019) – Jordan Peele’s horror film with an eerie underground doppelgänger society nods heavily to this idea.
- DC Comics and Marvel have both had mutant tunnel-dwelling communities under NYC.
Modern Sightings & Speculation
Even today, some subway workers and urban explorers swear they’ve heard whispers or seen shadowy figures moving just out of flashlight range — in places that should be empty.
One chilling modern twist? Some legends say the Mole People are growing in number — and that one day they’ll rise from below, taking back the surface that cast them out…
